Quadsville

Thu, Mar 11, 2010  | Sign Out | Account Settings
Loading...
Derek Jarman + Punk = Porn. Oh, and Art.
Posted by: Mayor Melissa on September 9, 2008 at 9:30AM CST
Saturday and Sunday could not have been two more opposite days. On Saturday, I visited Schloss Schönbrunn, the palace of the Hapsburg dynasty, with its gilded state rooms, symmetrical gardens and classic fountains. Sunday, I went to the Kunsthalle Wien, a contemporary art museum, and took in two related exhibits that explored the messy, violent and sexual side of human existence, complete with pornographic films and used tampons.

"Derek Jarman: Brutal Beauty" and "Punk: No One is Innocent" (especially not after viewing the exhibit) take the viewer to London, New York and Berlin during the 1970s when the punk movement defined fashion, attitude, and artistic expression and when genders were being flagrantly bent.

Let's start with Jarman. You may have seen some of his Super-8 video work if you are familiar with the music videos for The Smiths' "The Queen is Dead" and The Pet Shop Boys' "It's a Sin." He also directed some interesting takes on Shakespeare ("The Tempest") and Christopher Marlowe ("Edward II"). While gay themes and the horror of AIDS are often explored in his work, and graphically so, I don't find that disturbing like I do the mix of sex and violence explored in the Punk exhibit. But we'll get to that later.

The Jarman exhibit began with a film about his life, "Derek" directed by Isaac Julien and narrated by actress Tilda Swinton. It was shown on a large screen in surround sound with several large bean bags for viewers to sit on. In the next room, were a dozen or so screens of varying sizes, all showing different Super-8 films by Jarman. Since Super-8 is a silent medium, this works out well. Again, the bean bag chairs for comfortable viewing, and some paintings by Jarman were displayed in the corners of the room.

The third room contained more of his paintings and mixed media work, mostly late life works when his art was primarily a response to his battle with AIDS. In the final room, his film "Blue" was projected on a big screen. In it, Jarman describes his life and artistic vision at a time when he was blind and dying of AIDS-related complications. The visuals: a single screen shot of vibrant, saturated blue for the entire 55 minutes. The script was also published as a book.

I do see a truth and a beauty in Jarman's art. I had a harder time wrapping my mind around the punk movement as anything but reactionary, using vulgarity primarily for shock value. OK, I take that back. I like some of the music, some of the fashion and some of the art. But the main focus of the exhibit, as far as I could tell, was on extreme sex and violence as the defining qualities of punk.

If the Richard Kern film "Fingered" truly captures the Zeitgeist of the era, I'm glad I was but a wee babe then and so blissfully unaware of it. But, of course, I was raised in rural Illinois, not London or New York or Berlin, so chances are I could have still avoided it entirely had I been of sentient age.

Of particular interest to me is the neo-Punk movement that seems to be afoot here in Vienna (and probably other major international cities). There were several young people taking in the exhibit that also could have been part of it. In a loft area above the main exhibit was a smaller exhibit on the (original) punk scene in Vienna, which had been vandalized by someone who changed all the past tenses to present tenses in the placards explaining the exhibit. "F-- you! I AM a punk!" was scrawled on one piece of signage.

Maybe someone can explain to me why nihilism is attractive.

Send This | Categories:
(7) Comments
Posted by: matt on September 9, 2008 12:05PM CST
melissa - i've never heard of jarmin; i'll have to check him out sometime. have you seen much of David Wojnarowicz' work? if not, i can probably dig up a monograph sometime for you.

mike - that's interesting to hear about that facet of davenport in the early 80s (described in your first post). i was learning to ride my bike in '81, but later on in the mid 90s i was part of a similar type of crowd that you're describing. the Smile Coffeehouse downtown hosted a lot of underground music from all over the country, and people there often hung out and read, exchanged zines, talked about new records thay'd bought, and other such things. i miss that place and that feel. nowadays the local punk scene here is more rooted in "tough guy" hardcore, and that's not really my thing.

Posted by: matt on September 9, 2008 12:08PM CST
to add, i'm laughing about the "a lot of conformity in their non-conformity" sentence. that certainly is true, isn't it.

Posted by: matt on September 9, 2008 2:51PM CST
i seem to agree with you on a lot of this, mike. my initial immersion into punk rock music and the many smaller subcultures that come with it predates MTV's commodification of the poppier aspects of it (or, if not mtv, think Hot Topic (Topix?) mall stores and what-not). when it comes to how "things nowadays" make me feel, ian mackaye and guy piccioto of fugazi have a lot better way at words than i do, when they speak of what's happened to a marketing of "aggressive guitar music, for lack of a better word." all in all, like you, i look back and partially laugh as to the way i viewed this particular counterculture. back then, i idealistically thought we were making a bigger difference in the world than we actually were, and... as "be true to yourself" as i am... i definitely bought into the adopting of a particular physical look. i had my Minor Threat shaved head, i wore straightedge X's on my hands, etcetera etcetera. nowadays — fifteen years later — i still listen to a lot of awfully abrasive, obnoxious, fast punk rock music, but i've come to realize that's what it is about - the music itself, not a special signifier haircut or belt. the humorous thing is, i'm sure my 20 year old self got inwardly laughed with (not at) by 35 year olds who grew up in the early 80s music scene, just like i am now doing with current trends.

i'd love to see my daughter grow up to ask intellectually 'punk' questions about the way things work, just like i'll love it when she asks questions about life and her natural world. but if the former questions start to become trumped by a peer pressure-ish fashion/acceptance type of behavior, i'll have to try that hand at parenting that is illustrating an anecdotal walk down my memory lane, trying to point out it's best to just "be yourself." i'm not sure if any of this makes sense; i'm having a difficult time writing well today.

Loading...
About This Blog
Back from Austria. Writing about America again. Some international tidbits thrown in for good measure.

Rate this Blog:
0 rating(s)

Categories
Latest Entries
Loading...
Links
Loading...
Report Photos